Case Note – 117 Orphan Relative Visa [2025] ARTA 307

Home >

Blog >

Case Note – 117 Orphan Relative Visa [2025] ARTA 307

Get Your Question Answered

Case Details

At a glance

The Tribunal set aside refusals for two orphan relative applicants, accepting evidence that the parents were deceased/unknown whereabouts and finding PIC 4020 was met despite earlier “non-genuine document” concerns, so the cases were remitted.

Facts summary

• Two Subclass 117 applications were lodged in 2022, sponsored by an Australian citizen half-sibling.
• The Department refused in 2024, questioning whether the applicants’ mother was deceased and whether the father’s whereabouts were unknown, pointing to money transfers apparently made after claimed dates.
• The Department also treated certain documents (initial proof of death and tracing materials) as “non-genuine” and refused on PIC 4020.
• On review, additional identity material was produced showing money was sent to different people with similar names (used as intermediaries due to practical remittance/ID issues).
• DNA evidence supported the claimed sibling relationships.
• Evidence of tracing efforts regarding the father was provided, and the Tribunal accepted the tracing process had been exhausted.
• One applicant had turned 18 by the time of the Tribunal decision; the Tribunal applied the “turned 18” pathway in the time-of-decision criterion.

Decision

The Tribunal found the orphan relative criteria were met at application and (to the extent required) at decision, accepted the explanation for the money transfer anomalies, and concluded there was no evidence the applicants gave bogus documents or materially false information, so PIC 4020 was met and the matters were remitted for remaining requirements.

Why it matters

• Subclass 117 cases often hinge on proof of parental death/unknown whereabouts—“financial anomalies” like transfers can be explained with credible evidence (IDs, intermediaries, dates, and context).
• DNA testing can strongly support claimed family relationships where documentation is limited.
• PIC 4020 issues may be overcome where the Tribunal is satisfied documents are not bogus and concerns are based on misunderstandings or incomplete verification.
• Turning 18 during processing does not automatically end the case if the time-of-decision rule allows for it.

Need expert help?

Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and give you clear next steps.

✅ 30-minute consultation – $250

If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal fees. We assist clients across Australia and internationally.

Related Pages:

General information only — not legal advice. This note summarises an anonymised public decision. Outcomes vary. Seek a consultation for advice. .