Case note / [2025] ARTA 1563

Protection Visa and the Present Danger-to-Community Assessment

866 - Protection25 August 2025AdelaideSet aside and substituted - not a danger under section 36(1C)(b)
On this page

Issue

Whether an applicant convicted of a particularly serious crime remained a danger to the Australian community under section 36(1C)(b).

Facts

  • The applicant had a long offending history linked substantially to heroin dependence.
  • His most recent imprisonment followed heroin-trafficking offences, and he conceded the particularly-serious-crime limb.
  • Evidence indicated prolonged heroin abstinence, although other drug lapses occurred during immigration detention.
  • After release he had stable accommodation and continued opioid-substitution treatment; a psychologist supplied updated evidence.

Decision

Set aside and substituted with a finding that the applicant was not a danger to the community for section 36(1C)(b). The Tribunal assessed relapse risk as low on the individual evidence, departing from the psychologist's overall risk estimate while acknowledging grave potential harm.

Significance

Past serious crime and present danger were distinct elements. The decision resolved only this protection criterion: it neither granted a protection visa nor revoked the earlier visa cancellation, and was not a Direction 110 balancing exercise.

Source: [2025] ARTA 1563

General information about a published Tribunal decision, not legal advice. This summary reflects the law and circumstances considered in that decision. A similar issue does not mean another case will have the same outcome.

For advice about your own circumstances, a separate consultation is available.

Book a Consultation
Need advice?Speak with Jade
Book a consultation