Issue
Could promised private care overcome a valid adverse medical opinion affecting a combined aged parent visa application?
Facts
- The application included a primary applicant, a spouse and a dependent family member.
- The dependent family member required significant daily assistance because of a congenital condition.
- An Australian-citizen relative offered continuing family care without government financial assistance.
- The medical assessment predicted significant community-service costs; the family declined a further medical opinion at review.
Decision
The Tribunal found that the Medical Officer of the Commonwealth had applied the correct hypothetical-person test and accepted the opinion as binding. Failure of PIC 4005 prevented the dependent and other applicants from meeting the linked criteria. It affirmed all refusals while agreeing to refer the matter to the Department for ministerial consideration.
Significance
Actual willingness to fund care privately did not displace the statutory health assessment. Strong compassionate circumstances supported referral, but neither referral nor the possibility of ministerial intervention changed the affirmed refusals or amounted to a visa grant.
Source: [2025] ARTA 1709
General information about a published Tribunal decision, not legal advice. This summary reflects the law and circumstances considered in that decision. A similar issue does not mean another case will have the same outcome.
For advice about your own circumstances, a separate consultation is available.
Book a Consultation