Issue
Whether a regional business genuinely required a Retail Manager rather than a retail supervisor for its nominated position.
Facts
- The business combined a bakery with food retail operations over lengthy daily operating hours.
- Its owners undertook production and service work and could not cover all operating hours.
- The nominee managed purchasing, stock records, rosters, staff supervision and food-handling compliance.
- The employment contract provided a 38-hour week, and the business supplied evidence of continuing operations.
Decision
Set aside and remitted with regulation 2.72C(12) satisfied. The Tribunal found substantial alignment with Retail Manager duties and independent responsibility beyond a supervisory role, despite collaboration with the owners. It also accepted that the position was full-time and likely to exist for at least five years.
Significance
The Tribunal examined how the business actually operated and distributed managerial responsibilities. The order resolved specified nomination requirements, not the nominee's visa application or every remaining nomination criterion.
Source: [2025] ARTA 2144
General information about a published Tribunal decision, not legal advice. This summary reflects the law and circumstances considered in that decision. A similar issue does not mean another case will have the same outcome.
For advice about your own circumstances, a separate consultation is available.
Book a Consultation