Issue
Whether everyone legally entitled to determine a child's residence had consented to the visitor visa under PIC 4017, where the child was born through surrogacy.
Facts
- A child born through a surrogacy arrangement applied for a Subclass 600 visitor visa.
- The original material did not disclose the surrogacy arrangement, and no parenting court orders were available.
- The review included a DNA report, evidence of the parents' care of the child, and a Chinese legal opinion with supporting cases.
- The surrogate had not claimed parental rights, and no custody dispute or proceeding was identified.
Decision
Set aside and remitted. The Tribunal accepted the biological parents' custody rights and consent, finding PIC 4017 satisfied. The Department still had to consider the remaining visitor visa criteria.
Significance
Biological parentage and legal authority to consent were separate issues. The result depended on the evidence of custody and the relevant foreign law; it did not establish a general rule for all surrogacy arrangements.
Source: [2026] ARTA 2580
General information about a published Tribunal decision, not legal advice. This summary reflects the law and circumstances considered in that decision. A similar issue does not mean another case will have the same outcome.
For advice about your own circumstances, a separate consultation is available.
Book a Consultation