Case Note – 491 Visa Health [2024] AATA 2445

Home >

Blog >

Case Note – 491 Visa Health [2024] AATA 2445

Get Your Question Answered

Case Details

At a glance

A family applied for a Subclass 491 visa. The primary applicant was a registered nurse working in regional Australia. The application failed because the applicant’s son, who had Angelman syndrome, did not satisfy PIC 4005.

Facts summary

  • The primary applicant applied for a Subclass 491 visa as a registered nurse.
  • Her child was born in Australia and had Angelman syndrome with developmental delay and seizures.
  • The original refusal was based on PIC 4005 because the child was said to create a significant cost to the Australian community.

Decision

The Tribunal found the final RMOC opinion valid and accepted that the estimated cost of services would be a significant cost to the Australian community. Even so, the Tribunal considered the case strong enough to recommend Ministerial Intervention, noting the child’s circumstances and the mother’s work as a nurse in an area of shortage.

Why it matters

This case shows that in PIC 4005 cases, the validity of the MOC/RMOC opinion can be critical. If the wrong costs are counted, or the wrong assessment period is used, the opinion may be invalid.

Need expert help?

Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and give you clear next steps.

✅ 30-minute consultation – $250

If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal fees. We assist clients across Australia and internationally.

Related Pages:

General information only — not legal advice. This is an anonymised summary of a published Tribunal/Court decision. It may not reflect your circumstances and outcomes vary. Seek advice for your circumstances. .

Related case notes