Case Note – 572 Visa Health [2020] AATA 3841

Home >

Blog >

Case Note – 572 Visa Health [2020] AATA 3841

Get Your Question Answered

Case Details

At a glance

A Student visa application was refused because a secondary applicant child with cerebral palsy and intellectual impairment did not meet PIC 4005.

Facts summary

• A family applied for Student visas, with the child included as a secondary applicant.
• The child had cerebral palsy, used a wheelchair, needed help with daily living, and attended a special school.
• There was later litigation about whether the refusal notice had been properly sent to the authorised recipient.
• The Federal Circuit Court remitted the matter to the Tribunal for reconsideration.
• During the remitted review, the family said they had cared for the child privately in Australia without relying on government or community assistance.
• The Tribunal invited the applicant to obtain a further MOC opinion, but no fresh opinion was provided.

Decision

The Tribunal accepted that the family had cared for the child privately and at their own expense, but held that this did not answer the legal test because PIC 4005 applies regardless of whether the relevant services are actually used. The applicant also did not provide a fresh Medical Officer of the Commonwealth opinion despite being invited to do so. The refusal was affirmed, although the Tribunal referred the matter to the Minister for possible intervention given the long delay and the family’s circumstances in Australia.

Why it matters

This case shows the limits of compassionate or practical arguments where there is no waiver available under the relevant criterion.

Need expert help?

Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and give you clear next steps.

✅ 30-minute consultation – $250

If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal fees. We assist clients across Australia and internationally.

Related Pages:

General information only — not legal advice. This is an anonymised summary of a published Tribunal/Court decision. It may not reflect your circumstances and outcomes vary. Seek advice for your circumstances. .