Case Note – Partner Visa [2024] AATA 1434

Home >

Blog >

Case Note – Partner Visa [2024] AATA 1434

Get Your Question Answered

Case Details

At a glance

Whether the applicant and sponsor were in a genuine and continuing spousal relationship under s 5F at time of application and time of decision.

Facts summary

  • Applicant lodged a partner visa application based on their relationship with an Australian citizen sponsor.

  • The couple were married and relied on the spousal relationship criteria.

  • The application was refused because the Department was not satisfied the relationship met the “spouse” definition (genuine and continuing relationship / not living separately on a permanent basis).

  • The Tribunal considered information on the Department file that raised concerns and gave the applicant an opportunity to respond.

  • A key issue was inconsistent address information held by Centrelink; the Tribunal accepted the couple’s explanation and other evidence that they were in a genuine relationship and not permanently separated (including living arrangements influenced by the sponsor’s parenting responsibilities).

Decision

AAT remitted a Subclass 820 refusal, finding the couple’s relationship genuine despite Centrelink address inconsistencies explained by child-care and housing arrangements; evidence across financial, household, social and commitment factors supported s 5F.

Why it matters

This case matters because it shows that partner visa decisions turn on the real-life substance of the relationship, not just “perfect” paperwork.

It highlights that address inconsistencies in government records (e.g., Centrelink) can raise doubts about cohabitation, but they are not decisive if the couple can provide a credible explanation and supporting evidence across the relationship factors.

Need expert help?

Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and map out the way forward. Book your consultation today with Jade Immigration Lawyers.

✅ 30-minute consultation – $250
(If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal costs.)

💡 We assist clients across Australia and internationally. Let us handle the paperwork — so you can focus on your future.

Related Pages:

Disclaimer

General information only — not legal advice. This case note summarises a public decision and is anonymised for privacy. Outcomes depend on individual facts, current law and policy. For advice about your situation, please seek a consultation. .