Case Note – 790 Visa [2025] ARTA 2264

Home >

Blog >

Case Note – 790 Visa [2025] ARTA 2264

Get Your Question Answered

Case Details

At a glance

A SHEV was refused under s 501(1) because the applicant failed the character test (special verdict due to mental illness and ongoing forensic detention). The Tribunal accepted the past violence was extremely serious, but found the current risk was low under strict forensic supervision, and that refusing the visa would cause very serious legal and practical consequences (including ongoing restrictive BVR conditions and realistic third-country removal risk). The Tribunal set aside the refusal.

Facts summary

Applied for SHEV (790) after arriving in 2013.

Soon after, a violent incident caused one death and one serious injury.

Court found act proven but not criminally responsible (mental illness); applicant became a forensic patient under MHRT oversight.

Department later refused under s 501(1).

On review: clinically stable, on supervised leave, but only held a BVR with strict conditions; key issue was risk management + consequences (incl. third-country removal).

Decision

• The Tribunal found the applicant did not pass the character test (s 501(7)(e)).
• Applying Direction 110, it accepted the conduct was very serious, and community expectations weighed against the applicant.
• But it found community protection risk was low-to-moderate overall, heavily controlled by forensic mental health safeguards, and that refusal carried very substantial legal consequences (ongoing restrictive BVR conditions + increased uncertainty + realistic third-country removal risk affecting treatment and stability).
• On balance, the Tribunal set aside the refusal and substituted a decision not to refuse the SHEV.

Why it matters

Even where someone fails the character test, the Tribunal can still decide not to refuse under s 501(1) after weighing Direction 110 factors.

Need expert help?

Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and give you clear next steps.

✅ 30-minute consultation – $250

If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal fees. We assist clients across Australia and internationally.

Related Pages:

General information only — not legal advice. This note summarises an anonymised public decision. Outcomes vary. Seek a consultation for advice. .