Case Details
- [2024] AATA 138
- Subclass 188 (Business Innovation and Investment (Provisional))
- Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT)
- Affirmed
At a glance
This case involved a Subclass 188 visa refusal on PIC 4005 health grounds. The primary applicant had severe chronic renal disease, and the Tribunal accepted a valid Medical Officer of the Commonwealth opinion that a hypothetical person with that condition would likely require dialysis and possibly kidney transplant services, resulting in significant cost and prejudice to access for Australian citizens and permanent residents. The Tribunal affirmed the refusal.
Facts summary
- The applicants lodged a Subclass 188 visa application.
- The delegate refused the application because the first named applicant did not meet PIC 4005.
- The primary health issue was severe chronic renal disease.
- The applicant argued that he lived an active life, travelled, and would not rely on Australian medical services.
- The Tribunal obtained a fresh MOC opinion.
Decision
The Tribunal found that the latest MOC opinion was valid. The MOC identified the applicant’s condition as severe chronic renal disease, likely to be progressive, and concluded that the first named applicant did not satisfy PIC 4005(1)(c) and therefore did not satisfy cl 188.249.
Why it matters
This case highlights the important distinction between PIC 4005 and PIC 4007. In a PIC 4005 case, an applicant cannot succeed merely by arguing that they will self-fund treatment or avoid burdening the public system. Unlike PIC 4007 cases, there is no waiver mechanism to invite a broader balancing exercise.
Need expert help?
Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and give you clear next steps.
✅ 30-minute consultation – $250
If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal fees. We assist clients across Australia and internationally.
Related Pages:
General information only — not legal advice. This is an anonymised summary of a published Tribunal/Court decision. It may not reflect your circumstances and outcomes vary. Seek advice for your circumstances. .