Case Details
- [2024] AATA 4041
- Subclass 186 (ENS)
- Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT)
- Affirmed
At a glance
The Tribunal affirmed the refusal because the linked nomination was not approved (and effectively failed/was withdrawn in review), so cl 186.223(2) could not be satisfied and the Tribunal had no discretion.
Facts summary
• Subclass 186 (TRT) visa applications were lodged in October 2019.
• The Department refused the visa in January 2022 because the nomination was not approved.
• The nomination linked to the visa had been refused in March 2020.
• The nominator pursued review but a liquidator later withdrew from that process; the Tribunal finalised that withdrawal in April 2024.
• At the visa review hearing, the applicants did not produce evidence of any approved nomination.
• The Tribunal accepted the business closure was outside the applicants’ control, and noted delay and hardship, but found the legal requirement was mandatory.
Decision
Because there was no approved nomination attached to the visa application, the primary applicant could not meet cl 186.223, so the Tribunal affirmed the refusal and the secondary applicant necessarily failed the linked criteria.
Why it matters
• Nomination approval is foundational for ENS TRT: if cl 186.223(2) is not met, the visa cannot succeed regardless of hardship or fairness concerns.
• Where the nominator collapses / goes into liquidation, the visa can become practically unviable if the nomination review is withdrawn or cannot be revived.
• Delays in processing/review may feel unfair, but the Tribunal will often say it has no discretion where the regulation sets a strict prerequisite.
Need expert help?
Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and give you clear next steps.
✅ 30-minute consultation – $250
If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal fees. We assist clients across Australia and internationally.
Related Pages:
General information only — not legal advice. This note summarises an anonymised public decision. Outcomes vary. Seek a consultation for advice. .