Case Details
- [2024] AATA 4042
- New Zealand Citizen (Family Relationship) (Temporary) (Class UP
- Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT)
- Affirmed
At a glance
The Tribunal affirmed because the applicant lodged 9 days after her substantive visa ceased and could not satisfy Schedule 3 (criterion 3004(c)) (“factors beyond control”), but found strong hardship and referred the case to the Minister due to exceptional circumstances.
Facts summary
• The Subclass 461 application was lodged in Australia after the applicant’s substantive visa ceased (late lodgement by post).
• The Department refused because Schedule 3 criterion 3004(c) was not met.
• The applicant said delays and stressors affected timely lodgement, including:
o COVID-era delays affecting document timing (passport renewal / AFP check).
o Misunderstanding about a “grace period”.
o Family responsibilities, including children’s schooling/support needs.
o Later, serious illness in the family and caregiving responsibilities (raised in Tribunal material).
• The Tribunal accepted the pandemic and stressors existed, but found they did not cause the unlawful/non-substantive status because the applicant could have lodged without waiting for the documents.
• The Tribunal nevertheless accepted significant hardship to the family (including an Australian citizen child) if the applicant had to depart, with likely family separation and disruption.
Decision
The Tribunal held Schedule 3 criterion 3004(c) was not satisfied (the applicant’s lack of a substantive visa was not because of factors beyond her control), so cl 461.213 failed and the refusal had to be affirmed, while separately noting the case warranted ministerial referral.
Why it matters
• For onshore 461 applications lodged after a substantive visa ends, Schedule 3 is a hard gate: even strong hardship will not cure failure of 3004(c) if the applicant could realistically have lodged in time.
• Document delays (passport/police checks) may not help if the Tribunal considers the application could have been lodged first and documents provided later.
• Even where the Tribunal cannot grant, it may still refer under s 351 where there are unique/exceptional circumstances, especially involving serious hardship to an Australian citizen child and family unity.
Need expert help?
Speak with an experienced Australian immigration lawyer. We’ll assess your situation, explain your options, and give you clear next steps.
✅ 30-minute consultation – $250
If you proceed with us, this fee will be credited towards your legal fees. We assist clients across Australia and internationally.
Related Pages:
General information only — not legal advice. This note summarises an anonymised public decision. Outcomes vary. Seek a consultation for advice. .